Myanmar massacre: ‘My family died in front of my eyes’

Warning: This text incorporates particulars some readers might discover distressing.

Fayaz and his spouse believed they have been moments from security when the bombs started to fall: “We have been getting on the boat one after one other – that’s once they began bombing us.”

Wails and shouts crammed the air round 17:00 native time on 5 August, Fayaz* says, as 1000’s of scared Rohingyas made their strategy to the banks of the Naf river within the city of Maungdaw.

Assaults on villages earlier within the space meant this was what a whole bunch of households, together with Fayaz’s, noticed as their solely choice – that to get to security, they needed to escape from western Myanmar to Bangladesh’s safer shores.

Fayaz was carrying luggage full of no matter they’d managed to seize. His spouse was carrying their six-year-old daughter, their eldest was operating alongside them. His spouse’s sister was strolling forward, with the couple’s eight-month-old son in her arms.

The primary bomb killed his sister-in-law immediately. The child was badly injured – however alive.

“I ran and carried him… However he died whereas we have been ready for the bombing to cease.”

Nisar* had additionally made it to the riverbank by about 17:00, having determined to flee along with his mom, spouse, son, daughter and sister. “We heard drones overhead after which the loud sound of an explosion,” he recollects. “We have been all thrown to the bottom. They dropped bombs on us utilizing drones.”

Nisar was the one one in all his household to outlive.

Fayaz, his spouse and daughter escaped and would ultimately make it throughout the river. Regardless of his pleas, the boatman refused to permit Fayaz to convey the infant’s physique with them. “He mentioned there was no level in carrying the lifeless, so I dug a gap by the river financial institution and swiftly buried him.”

Now they’re all within the relative security of Bangladesh, but when they’re caught by authorities right here they could possibly be despatched again. Nisar clutches a Quran, unable nonetheless to course of how his world was shattered in a single day.

“If I’d recognized what would occur, I might by no means have tried to go away that day,” Nisar says.

It’s notoriously troublesome to piece collectively what is occurring in Myanmar’s civil warfare. However the BBC has managed to assemble an image of what occurred on the night of 5 August by way of a collection of unique interviews with greater than a dozen Rohingya survivors who escaped to Bangladesh, and the movies they shared.

The entire survivors – unarmed Rohingya civilians – recount listening to many bombs exploding over a interval of two hours. Whereas most described the bombs being dropped by drones, a weapon more and more being utilized in Myanmar, some mentioned they have been hit by mortars and gunfire. The MSF clinic working in Bangladesh has mentioned it noticed an enormous surge in wounded Rohingya within the days that adopted – half of the injured have been ladies and kids.

Survivors’ movies analysed by BBC Confirm present the river financial institution coated in bloodied our bodies, lots of them ladies and kids. There’s no verified depend of the variety of folks killed, however a number of eyewitnesses have advised the BBC they noticed scores of our bodies.

Survivors advised us they have been attacked by the Arakan Military, one of many strongest rebel teams in Myanmar which in current months has pushed the army out of practically all of Rakhine State. They mentioned they have been first attacked of their villages, forcing them to flee, after which have been attacked once more by the river financial institution as they sought to flee.

The AA declined to be interviewed however its spokesman Khaing Tukha denied the accusation and responded to the BBC’s questions with a press release which mentioned “the incident didn’t happen in areas managed by us”. He additionally accused Rohingya activists of staging the bloodbath and falsely accusing the AA.

Nisar stands by his account, nonetheless.

“The Arakan Military are mendacity,” he says. “The assaults have been accomplished by them. It was solely them in our space on that day. They usually have been attacking us for weeks. They don’t wish to depart any Muslim alive.”

Most of Myanmar’s Rohingya Muslims dwell as a minority in Rakhine – a Buddhist-majority state, the place the 2 communities have lengthy had a fraught relationship. In 2017, when the Myanmar army killed 1000’s of Rohingyas in what the UN described as “a textbook instance of ethnic cleaning”, native Rakhine males additionally joined the assaults. Now, amid a spiralling battle between the junta and the AA, which has sturdy assist within the ethnic Rakhine inhabitants, Rohingyas as soon as once more discover themselves trapped.

Regardless of the chance of being caught and returned to Myanmar by the Bangladeshi authorities, Rohingya survivors advised the BBC they wished to share particulars of the violence they confronted so it will not go undocumented, particularly because it unfolded in an space that’s not accessible to rights teams or journalists.

“My coronary heart is damaged. Now, I’ve misplaced every thing. I don’t know why I survived,” Nisar says.

A rich Rohingya dealer, he bought his land and home because the shelling elevated close to his house in Rakhine. However the battle intensified sooner than he anticipated, and on the morning of 5 August, the household determined to go away Myanmar.

He’s crying as he factors to his daughter’s physique in one of many movies: “My daughter died in my arms saying Allah’s title. She seems to be so peaceable, like she’s sleeping. She liked me a lot.”

In the identical video, he additionally factors to his spouse and sister, each severely injured however alive when the video was filmed. He couldn’t carry them out as bombs have been nonetheless falling, so he made the agonising alternative to go away them behind. He came upon later they’d died.

“There was nowhere left that was secure, so we ran to the river to cross over to Bangladesh,” Fayaz says. The gunfire and bombs had adopted them from village to village, and so Fayaz gave all his cash to a boatman to hold them throughout the river.

Devastated and indignant, he holds up a photograph of his son’s bloodied physique.

“If the Arakan Military didn’t hearth at us, then who did?” he asks. “The route that the bombs got here from, I do know the Arakan Military was there. Or was it thunder falling from the sky?”

These accusations increase severe questions concerning the Arakan Military, which describes itself as a revolutionary motion representing all of the folks of Rakhine.

Since late final 12 months, the AA, a part of the bigger Three Brotherhood Alliance of armed insurgents in Myanmar, has made enormous good points in opposition to the army.

However the military’s losses have introduced new risks for Rohingyas, who’ve beforehand advised the BBC they have been being forcibly recruited by the junta to struggle the AA.

This, along with the choice by the Rohingya militant group ARSA to ally itself with the junta in opposition to the Rakhine insurgents, has soured already poor relations between the 2 communities and left Rohingya civilians weak to retribution.

One survivor of the 5 August assault advised the BBC that ARSA militants who had aligned themselves with the junta had been among the many fleeing crowd – and that may have provoked the assault.

“Even when there was any army goal, there was a disproportionate use of pressure. There have been youngsters, ladies, the aged that have been killed that day. It was additionally indiscriminate,” says John Quinley, a director of the human rights group Fortify Rights, which has been investigating the incident.

“In order that would depart us to consider that there are affordable grounds to consider {that a} warfare crime did occur on 5 August. The Arakan Military needs to be investigated for these crimes and Arakan Military senior commanders needs to be held accountable.”

This can be a precarious second for the Rohingya group. Greater than one million of them fled to Bangladesh in 2017, the place they proceed to be restricted to densely-packed, squalid camps.

Extra have been arriving in current months because the warfare in Rakhine reaches them however, it’s not 2017, when Bangladesh opened its borders. This time, the federal government has mentioned it can’t enable any extra Rohingyas into the nation.

So survivors who can discover the cash to pay boatmen and traffickers – the BBC was advised it prices 600,000 Burmese kyat ($184; £141) per individual – then have to slide previous Bangladeshi border guards and probability their luck with locals, or conceal in Rohingya camps.

When Fayaz and his household arrived in Bangladesh on the 6 August, the border guards gave them a meal however then put them on a ship and despatched them again.

“We spent two days afloat with no meals or water,” he says. “I gave my daughters water from the river to drink, and pleaded with a few of the others on the boat to present them a number of biscuits from the packets they’d.”

They acquired into Bangladesh on their second try. However a minimum of two boats have capsized due to overcrowding. One girl, a widow with 10 youngsters, mentioned she had managed to cover her household throughout the bombing, however 5 of her youngsters drowned when their boat overturned.

“My youngsters have been like items of my coronary heart. After I consider them, I wish to die,” she says, weeping.

Her grandson, a wide-eyed eight-year-old boy, sits beside her. His mother and father and youthful brother additionally died.

However what of those that have been left behind? Telephone and web networks in Maungdaw have been down for weeks however after repeated makes an attempt, the BBC contacted one man, who wished to stay nameless for his personal security.

“The Arakan Military has pressured us out of our houses and are holding us in faculties and mosques,” he mentioned. “I’m being saved with six different households in a small home.”

The Arakan Military advised the BBC that it rescued 20,000 civilians from the city amid combating in opposition to the army. It mentioned it was offering them with meals and medical therapy, and add that “these operations are performed for the protection and safety of those people, not as pressured relocations”.

The person on the telephone rejected their claims. “The Arakan Military has advised us they are going to shoot us if we attempt to depart. We’re operating out of meals and medicines. I’m sick, my mom is sick. Lots of people have diarrhoea and are vomiting.”

He broke down, pleading for assist: “Tens of 1000’s of Rohingya are beneath menace right here. When you can, please save us.”

Throughout the river in Bangladesh, Nisar seems to be again at Myanmar. He can see the shore the place his household was killed.

“I by no means wish to return.”

Further reporting by Aamir Peerzada and Sanjay Ganguly

* Names have been modified on request